Ideal CityOpen the map

Pondera Colony vs Shelby

Pondera Colony, Montana versus Shelby, Montana: a factual, side-by-side comparison of cost of living, housing, safety, schools, and climate. Greener figures rank better among US places.

Overall livability

Pondera Colony

Mixed · objective livability45/100

Shelby

Solid · objective livability51/100

Shelby edges out Pondera Colony on overall objective livability (51 vs 45 of 100), though each leads on different factors below.

Factor-by-factor comparison

FactorPondera ColonyShelby
Affordability
Median Household Income$52k
Cost of Living$51k$49k
Home Value$181k
Monthly Rent$720
Monthly Owner Costs$0$732
Property Tax Rate1.02%
Income Tax5.90%5.90%
Sales Tax0.00%0.00%
Estimated total tax burden9.50%
Unemployment10.0%1.3%
Weather
Winter Temp (Jan)23°F23°F
Summer Temp (Jul)64°F65°F
Annual Precipitation12.6 in12.1 in
Annual Snowfall46.8 in38.9 in
Sunny Days239 days257 days
Summer Humidity48°F48°F
Comfortable Days46 days47 days
Safety & Wellbeing
Natural Disaster Risk87.347.8
Air Quality24 AQI24 AQI
School Quality67.533.2
Violent Crime590/100k0/100k
Property Crime877/100k0/100k
Community
Population403,058
Median Age40.542.7
Racial Diversity0.100.31
Male/Female Ratio1.861.56
Political LeaningR+38R+55
White (%)95.0%79.6%
Black (%)0.0%2.6%
Hispanic (%)0.0%5.4%
Asian (%)0.0%1.1%
Other / Multiracial (%)5.0%11.3%
Getting Around
Walkability5.5/204.9/20
Airport Distance241 mi268 mi
Lifestyle & Connectivity
Broadband Access0.0%88.5%
Amenities Nearby500.0058.86
Park & Nature AccessLimitedLimited

Each figure is colored by how it ranks among all US places: green is strong, amber average, red weaker. Neutral factors (population, demographics, target-style climate) show their percentile without a better/worse claim.

Frequently asked questions

Is Pondera Colony or Shelby more affordable?
Shelby has the lower cost of living: its index is $49k, compared with Pondera Colony's $51k and Shelby's $49k.
Is Pondera Colony or Shelby safer?
Shelby has the lower violent crime rate. Pondera Colony reports 590/100k and Shelby reports 0/100k (violent crimes per 100,000 residents).
See each on the map

Explore Pondera ColonyExplore Shelby

Full profiles